Sijal · Session minutes

Should our endowment's investment committee allocate 10% of the portfolio to private credit funds over the next three years?

Illustrative example: the institution and figures are hypothetical; the session is real.

Session minutes

Session details

Question
Should our endowment's investment committee allocate 10% of the portfolio to private credit funds over the next three years?
Completed
2026-11-11 14:30 UTC
Procedure version
3
Sides
The case for and the case against

Session instructions

An illustrative university endowment in the Gulf, about USD 400 million. Current allocation: 45% public equities, 35% investment-grade bonds and sukuk, 10% real estate, 10% cash. The endowment pays out 4.5% a year to fund scholarships and research, and that payout cannot be cut without board approval. The chief investment officer proposes committing 10% (about USD 40 million) to two or three private credit funds over three years, with expected net returns of 8 to 10% a year and capital locked for 5 to 7 years. The committee meets quarterly, has no in-house private markets team, and would rely on an external adviser for manager selection.

1

Liquidity and downside: can the endowment carry private credit's lock-ups and default risk through a downturn without breaking its annual spending commitments?

Votes on this goal

5The case for
1The case against

Goal outcome: The case for

Seat verdicts

  1. Seat 1The case for
  2. Seat 2The case against
  3. Seat 3The case for
  4. Seat 4The case for
  5. Seat 5The case for
  6. Seat 6The case for
2

Return after fees: does private credit's expected net return justify it over the investment-grade bonds and sukuk the endowment already holds?

Votes on this goal

2The case for
4The case against

Goal outcome: The case against

Seat verdicts

  1. Seat 1The case against
  2. Seat 2The case against
  3. Seat 3The case for
  4. Seat 4The case against
  5. Seat 5The case against
  6. Seat 6The case for
3

Governance and capability: does the committee have the expertise and oversight to select and monitor private credit managers?

Votes on this goal

0The case for
6The case against

Goal outcome: The case against

Seat verdicts

  1. Seat 1The case against
  2. Seat 2The case against
  3. Seat 3The case against
  4. Seat 4The case against
  5. Seat 5The case against
  6. Seat 6The case against

Overall result

The Court found for the case against

Goals for the case for 1 · Goals for the case against 2 · Votes 7 : 11

Decision record

Record number 15

Record integrity fingerprint

46d023af5cfecac6f9fd33d70ba125b70778426eeaba95a6b050eb9cf41c0a37

The session follows a procedure inspired by parliamentary procedure. These minutes display what is stored in the record and add nothing to it. The full reasons are on the result page.

Full result page