Should our endowment's investment committee allocate 10% of the portfolio to private credit funds over the next three years?
Illustrative example: the institution and figures are hypothetical; the session is real.
Session minutes
Session details
Session instructions
An illustrative university endowment in the Gulf, about USD 400 million. Current allocation: 45% public equities, 35% investment-grade bonds and sukuk, 10% real estate, 10% cash. The endowment pays out 4.5% a year to fund scholarships and research, and that payout cannot be cut without board approval. The chief investment officer proposes committing 10% (about USD 40 million) to two or three private credit funds over three years, with expected net returns of 8 to 10% a year and capital locked for 5 to 7 years. The committee meets quarterly, has no in-house private markets team, and would rely on an external adviser for manager selection.
Liquidity and downside: can the endowment carry private credit's lock-ups and default risk through a downturn without breaking its annual spending commitments?
Votes on this goal
Goal outcome: The case for
Seat verdicts
- Seat 1The case for
- Seat 2The case against
- Seat 3The case for
- Seat 4The case for
- Seat 5The case for
- Seat 6The case for
Return after fees: does private credit's expected net return justify it over the investment-grade bonds and sukuk the endowment already holds?
Votes on this goal
Goal outcome: The case against
Seat verdicts
- Seat 1The case against
- Seat 2The case against
- Seat 3The case for
- Seat 4The case against
- Seat 5The case against
- Seat 6The case for
Governance and capability: does the committee have the expertise and oversight to select and monitor private credit managers?
Votes on this goal
Goal outcome: The case against
Seat verdicts
- Seat 1The case against
- Seat 2The case against
- Seat 3The case against
- Seat 4The case against
- Seat 5The case against
- Seat 6The case against
Overall result
Goals for the case for 1 · Goals for the case against 2 · Votes 7 : 11
Decision record
Record number 15
Record integrity fingerprint
46d023af5cfecac6f9fd33d70ba125b70778426eeaba95a6b050eb9cf41c0a37
The session follows a procedure inspired by parliamentary procedure. These minutes display what is stored in the record and add nothing to it. The full reasons are on the result page.