SIJAL · INSTITUTIONAL REASONING ENGINE

Hear the other side at full strength, before you decide.

THE CASE FORargued in full
THE CASE AGAINSTby a

SIX JUDGES RULE BETWEEN THEM

Each side is argued in full and answers the other, under cross-examination. Six independent judges rule, and you receive a decision and a file you can defend.

ADJUDICATION
METHOD

Independent aggregated judgment, as in the Good Judgment Project (IARPA ACE programme)

Six judges. None sees another’s ruling.

Their judgments are aggregated by vote. Every ruling cites the references it rests on, and the objections that survive stay on the record.

foragainstone lens, 4-2
  • Lens 1: the case against2-4
  • Lens 2: the case for4-2
  • Lens 3: the case for4-2

Decision: the case for prevails in 2 of 3 lenses.

REPORT
METHOD

ICD 203 analytic standards, including analysis of alternatives

A decision, and the case against it, in one file.

WHAT YOU RECEIVE
  1. The other side, at full strength.
  2. A tested decision, with the objections that survived.
  3. A file you can defend.
DECISION FILE · SAMPLE

The case for · 2 of 3 lenses

THE CASE AGAINST, AT FULL STRENGTH

Won lens 1, 2-4. Its argument is kept in full.

OBJECTIONS THAT SURVIVED

  • The timing of the policy window is not established.
  • Remaining staff capacity is not quantified.

REFERENCES

  • [1] claim
  • [2] fact
  • [3] inference
WHO IT IS FOR

Organisations that must justify a judgment to others.

  • Research and policy centres

    A recommendation before a funder

  • Investment committees

    A deal before approval

  • Consulting firms

    A recommendation before delivery

  • NGOs

    Priorities before donors

  • Universities

    A decision before the curriculum or planning committee

  • Boards of directors

    A decision before shareholders

QUESTIONS

Answered plainly.

Isn’t this just AI answering a question?

No. One answer is one voice. Sijal argues each side under cross-examination, with a devil’s advocate assigned to the case against, then six judges rule independently. You get the strongest case against your position, on the record.

Can it be wrong?

Yes. No method is right every time, so Sijal doesn’t ask for your trust: it shows its work. The case against is argued in full, every ruling cites the references it rests on, and the objections that survived stay in the file. If a ruling is wrong, you can see exactly where, and so can anyone who reviews it. A single AI answer gives you nothing to check.

Who is accountable?

You are. The decision stays with the person who makes it; Sijal gives them what they need to defend it.

Who can see our session?

Your session’s members, anyone you give a view link to, and our operations team.

See the other side argued, before you decide.